L O S T - one audience member
Facebookers - this is probably cut off. Importing doesn't work right anymore. You can read it, should you care, at http://ciceroinpants.blogspot.com
I didn't expect Lost to do what it was supposed to do. This allowed me to enjoy the finale in spite of what it was. So I'm not enraged at Lost per se, and some of what it did I quite liked - like the resolution of the sideways timeline. That said, to hell with 'em anyway. What do you mean "it was about the characters?"
"It's about the characters" is a basic bait and switch. It's burned me before with Battlestar Galactica.
Lost wasn't Melrose Place or Guiding Light. It wasn't a soap opera. The story was not really driven by the interplay between the characters. It was driven by the interplay between the characters and the mysteries of the island. The question isn't "what was the show about". The question is "what was attracting viewers to watch the show"?
To be sure, viewers liked the charismatic characters - if you don't like a drama's characters you don't care about their fate - but what the show sold was mystery. Even more so than with BSG, because in BSG character interplay really was on an equal footing, or even more important, than the mysteries.In Lost, character motivation would change like the wind to support the needs of this week's plot. The plot itself was actually in service of the cliffhanger hooks - whether for commercial break, episode or season. The hooks were supposed to keep you watching (the ads) and everything worked backwards from there. That's bait in a very literal sense.
When a TV program offers mysteries like this, it intimates that it has answers which, if you tune in next week, will be revealed. The Lost writers did more than intimate though, once people started threatening to stop watching if they didn't know where they were going. They changed their tune in interviews to reassure their viewers that answers would come. (As the series neared its end they started to dial back on this and said the big mysteries would be resolved or the mysteries that were important to the characters. Screw the audience's expectations.)
What is sad is that in both the case of BSG and Lost, there is a subset of the fan base that will now convince themselves that they didn't care about the mysteries and don't care about being defrauded. That thinks its ok to make promises and not deliver on them, or weasel out with an "I never promised ha ha ha" when they knew the audience's expectations full well.
Whatever. I've learned my lesson. I've grown up. I'm less naive. I now know how television writing works. Get the cliffhanger image, work backward from there, don't worry about the resolution. Resolution doesn't sell ads. Once Lost is over there's no more ads to sell.
So I'm done investing in shows that promise arc mysteries. Fringe can sod off. See those ads for "The Event", ABC's Lost replacement? Forget it. I already refused to even look at Caprica.
People are being defrauded and thanking the fraudster. There's now an ethos that says it's perfectly acceptable, even artistically preferable, not to fulfill dramatic promises made.
I'm not on board. Have fun with it, Charlie Brown. When Lucy pulls the football away next time, don't say I didn't warn you.
A poster on one of the message boards I frequent, reddit.com, posted this little gem of a rant that I just had to keep for posterity. I don't agree with all of the vociferousness and language, but there's a certain hilarity to its whole "I'm mad as hell and not gonna take it anymore" sponteneity that I couldn't resist. Those easily offended by, oh whatever, might want to skip it.
Antihostile writes:
"Things I learned about Canada in the last little while:
You can be charged with drunk driving if you're drunk and near a car, the RCMP lie when they taser and kill people, the leader of the opposition is a milquetoast who can't make up his mind, the PM is a fascist, they're introducing mandatory minimum sentencing drug laws that have helped destroy the U.S., text-message fees are marked up 4900%, our health minister believes in non-nuclear isotopes, our Science Minister doesn't believe in evolution, the Federal Natural Resources Minister has a complete retard for an assistant, the Brampton MP abuses her household help and our MPs quietly and secretly decided that they will not reveal how they claim expenses just in case the scandal that brought down the Brit MPs causes the same fury here. WHAT A GREAT COUNTRY!"
Another poster then added:
"Also, our Mint lost $20 Million worth of gold. And the (recently re-elected) Premier of BC plead guilty to drunk driving while on vacation in Hawaii but the liberals called for the resignation of the NDP solicitor general for getting too many speeding tickets."
Fun.